Book review

Richard Kahn

On Breathing: Care in a Time of Catastrophe

Jamieson Webster. Catapult, 2025.

Breathing is the basic Zen practice technique. Just inhale and exhale with a little emphasis on the exhale. Breathing was analyzed by Jamieson Webster, a psychoanalyst and professor of psychoanalysis. We lie down next to her patients’ couch to gain insight into our own breathing.

Webster tells us that breathing represents the first big change in life when we leave the watery uterus and umbilical cord that supplies us with oxygen and food and enter the gaseous environment of air and breathing. She calls this trauma but maybe this change is better viewed as a shift to relationship. She also neglects eating, which is no longer involuntary. We start our interdependent life. Air and food need our participation. Meditators and yogis using breath know this.

She links breath to speech, notably how it expresses emotion. The organs of breathing and speech developed from gills so our breathing and speech return us to our oceanic past in the womb.

Webster reads widely and we benefit. I enjoy getting leads on suggestions for future reading. Here are two surprises. She explored whooping, hollering, ritual interrupting, and physically moving participation of the Black Pentecostal church service. Spirited and spiritual sounds are based on breathing. Her psychoanalytical view sees such vocalizations as rebellions. Glossolalia, speaking in tongues, can be seen as resistance against the ‘rationality’ that justifies oppression. All that shouting is a kind of ethereal community building.

These ideas derive from Ashon T. Crawley’s book Blackpentecostal Breath: The Aesthetics of Possibility. Crawley’s is one of many books Webster summarizes that tantalized me. She also awakens us to the depths of the classic bedtime book Goodnight Moon by Margaret Wise Brown. Webster emphasizes the incantatory repetitions of the words “good night” and goes beyond the book’s familiar warmth. The little picture book with simple text hides depth. Brown’s book has more to it than meets the eye and ear. The span between Sunday morning shouts and bedtime story includes much and so I recommend the book to those who want their Zen practice informed by ideas and feelings.

On Breathing is a kind of unintentional analytical mirror to Zen practice. I say that because Webster did not apply her otherwise keen eye to meditative silence. We Zen students and teachers definitely breathe, talk to ourselves, or repeat mantras during our respirations. She is not kind towards meditation and dismisses meditation in a few curt sentences even though many styles of meditation are based on breathing. Cannot group silence build community? A “katz” shout is also a form of glossolalia as is an exhaled slap to the floor.

Another detail mirrored in her idea world is a Greek philosopher, Anaxagoras, who thought we are all connected through a universal mind and a shared use of air and water along with plants. Our interviews connect student and teacher with words and gestures. She calls this kind of interconnection as a shared immersion. The interpersonal connection during interviews and immersion in the centuries of Zen writing were not placed under the analytic microscope. Given the current state of research examining meditation on the mind-body, the sword in the stone was left unturned. I hope to ask Jamieson, one day, about her thoughts on meditation. After all, I don’t know everything about her. I am waiting for an invitation for one of her upcoming talks. Until then, I won’t hold my breath.

[next article]